I thought my tenants had simply destroyed my backyard without permission. Then I found something buried beneath the dirt, and the way they reacted told me the hole was never really about a pool.
Advertisement
My name is Linda, and I own a rental property which I leased to a young couple.
They seemed perfectly normal when they signed the agreement six months ago.
One weekend, I drove over to drop off a maintenance notice and nearly ran off the road when I saw the backyard.
It had a massive hole in it that was roughly 15 feet across and at least five feet deep, with dirt piled in mounds along the fence line like something out of a construction site.
There had been no permit, no phone call, and not even a text message asking if this might possibly be okay with me.
For a few seconds, I simply sat behind the wheel and stared.
Then, I parked so quickly that one tire bumped the curb.
I marched up the front walk with the maintenance notice crushed in my hand and knocked hard enough to hurt my knuckles.
Brent, one of my tenants, answered the door.
He was a man in his early 30s who had always been polite whenever we spoke.
Advertisement
His wife, Kayla, usually handled the rent payments and occasional maintenance questions.
Brent smiled at me as though I had stopped by for coffee.
“Linda, hey.”
I pointed toward the side yard.
“What happened to my backyard?”
His expression shifted, but only slightly.
“Oh, that.”
“Yes, Brent, that.”
Kayla appeared behind him, and the nervous look on her face immediately told me that at least one of them understood how outrageous this was.
Brent stepped onto the porch and explained that they’d always wanted an in-ground pool and figured they’d just “get started” before formally asking me, since I’d probably say yes eventually anyway.
I stared at him.
“You dug a 15-foot hole in property you do not own because you thought I would probably say yes?”
“We were going to talk to you,” Kayla said.
Advertisement
“When?”
She opened her mouth, then closed it.
I turned back to Brent and asked, “Did you pull a permit?”
His silence answered me.
I could feel heat rising into my face.
“This is a rental property, and you can’t decide to excavate the backyard.”
“We were planning to improve it,” Brent argued. “A pool adds value.”
“Not when the owner never agreed to one.”
He sighed as though I were being difficult, and that irritated me almost more than the hole itself.
I told them I was calling the city that same afternoon to report unauthorized excavation on my own property, and I fully meant it.
Kayla’s face went pale.
“Do you really have to do that?”
“Yes.”
“Linda, maybe we can just fill it back in,” she said quickly.
Advertisement
I almost laughed.
“You should have thought about that before digging it.”
I walked around back one more time to take photographs for the report.
I became angrier with every picture I took because the grass was destroyed, one section of fencing had been loosened, and dirt covered part of the patio.
I climbed down into the hole myself to get a better photograph of the depth for the inspector.
“Linda,” Kayla called from above, “you don’t need to go down there.”
“I need photographs.”
“It’s uneven.”
“I can see that.”
I took several pictures, including one with the bottom of the fence visible behind me for scale.
Then, as I stepped backward, I felt something hard beneath my shoes.
It was not a rock.
I dragged my foot slowly across the dirt again, and this time something metallic caught the afternoon sunlight.
Advertisement
I crouched down.
A narrow strip of dull gray metal was sticking through the packed earth.
I looked up.
Brent and Kayla were both standing at the edge of the hole.